Electric power, plenty of BMWs, and a handful of unexpected favorites.

2019 was a year packed with memorable drives and an impressive variety of new cars and trucks. Over roughly 350 days, Motor1.com published nearly 200 reviews and first-drive impressions, giving us plenty of opportunities to put the latest vehicles through their paces. With the year winding down, it was time to look back at the models that made the strongest impressions.
For this ranking, the focus was on vehicles the team actually spent substantial time with at its bases in Detroit, Miami, and Cleveland. That means this list isn’t filled with cars sampled for a few hours at an international launch or driven briefly at a remote test track. These were vehicles we lived with, drove in everyday conditions, and evaluated as products you could actually buy.
And there was plenty to choose from.
The 2019 reviews revealed several interesting trends. Electrification made a major impact, with two of the top three vehicles using electric power and the No. 1 vehicle featuring an electrified powertrain. At the same time, traditional internal-combustion engines remained very much alive, particularly in the performance and luxury segments.
BMW was arguably the biggest winner of the year, placing five vehicles on the final 20-car list. Its entries covered everything from sporty sedans and coupes to SUVs, showing just how broad the automaker’s lineup had become.
South Korea also had a strong showing, with two highly rated vehicles, while German manufacturers dominated the overall rankings. BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Porsche, and Audi collectively accounted for half of the 20 vehicles.Here are the 20 cars and trucks that stood out most from our 2019 testing.
Table of Contents
Kia Telluride

The Kia Telluride arrived as one of the year’s biggest surprises. Its bold styling, spacious three-row cabin, comfortable ride, and generous equipment made it a serious competitor in the midsize SUV market. More importantly, it offered the kind of refinement that could make shoppers reconsider the traditional luxury brands.
Volvo S60
The Volvo S60 brought Scandinavian design and understated performance to the luxury-sedan segment. Its beautifully finished cabin, comfortable seats, advanced safety technology, and available performance-oriented powertrains gave it plenty of character in a crowded class.
Ford F-150

The Ford F-150 remained one of America’s most important vehicles, and for good reason. Its broad range of engines, impressive towing and hauling capability, comfortable interior, and enormous selection of configurations made it equally useful as a workhorse and daily driver.
Mercedes-AMG GT 53

The Mercedes-AMG GT 53 demonstrated that performance and luxury could coexist in a four-door package. Its sleek styling, sophisticated cabin, turbocharged powertrain, and AMG-tuned chassis gave it the character of a sports car with the practicality of a sedan.
BMW 750i

The BMW 750i represented the luxury side of BMW’s lineup at its best. Its powerful V8, exceptionally comfortable cabin, advanced technology, and polished road manners made it an impressive long-distance cruiser while retaining enough performance to keep enthusiasts interested.
Acura RDX

The RDX showed how far Acura’s midsize luxury crossover had evolved. Its sharp exterior, spacious cabin, responsive handling, and turbocharged four-cylinder engine gave it a strong combination of practicality and driving enjoyment.
BMW X5

The redesigned X5 continued BMW’s push into the luxury-SUV market without abandoning its performance roots. It combined a high-quality interior and advanced technology with strong engines and surprisingly athletic handling for a vehicle of its size.
BMW X7

The BMW X7 brought three-row practicality to the brand’s SUV lineup while maintaining the premium experience expected from BMW. Its spacious cabin, upscale materials, powerful engines, and comfortable ride made it a compelling alternative to established luxury SUVs.
Porsche Cayenne

The Porsche Cayenne proved that a large SUV could still deliver genuine driving excitement. Strong engines, sharp steering, sophisticated suspension technology, and excellent road manners gave it a distinctly Porsche-like character despite its considerable size.
Honda Odyssey

The Honda Odyssey showed that minivans still have plenty to offer. Its roomy interior, clever storage solutions, comfortable seating, and family-focused technology made it one of the most practical vehicles on the road, while its refined driving experience made long trips considerably easier.
BMW M2 Competition

The M2 Competition was one of the year’s standout driver’s cars. Its twin-turbocharged inline-six, rear-wheel-drive layout, compact dimensions, and aggressive chassis tuning created a sports coupe that felt genuinely special without requiring a supercar budget.
BMW Z4

The redesigned Z4 brought back the classic two-seat roadster formula with modern BMW engineering. Rear-wheel drive, a powerful available six-cylinder engine, and a retractable soft top made it a natural choice for enthusiasts looking for open-air performance.
Mazda3
The Mazda3 continued to demonstrate that an affordable compact car doesn’t have to be boring. Its elegant design, upscale cabin, precise handling, and polished ride gave it a premium feel that exceeded expectations for its price class.
Hyundai Santa Fe

The Santa Fe delivered a well-rounded combination of comfort, practicality, technology, and value. Its spacious interior and extensive safety equipment made it especially appealing to families, while its refined driving manners kept it competitive with more established rivals.
Audi Q8

Audi’s flagship crossover coupe brought dramatic styling and a luxurious interior to the SUV segment. The Q8 combined strong performance with sophisticated technology and a high-quality cabin, giving it plenty of appeal for buyers seeking something more distinctive.
Ford Edge

The 2019 Ford Edge received a fresh round of updates that made the midsize crossover more appealing both on the road and inside the cabin. The standard turbocharged 2.0-liter four-cylinder delivered 250 horsepower, while the Edge ST brought a 335-hp twin-turbocharged 2.7-liter V6 and all-wheel drive for a much sportier take on the family crossover. With a comfortable interior, useful cargo space, and a surprising amount of performance in ST form, the Edge gave us plenty to explore during our 2019 testing.
Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid

The Pacifica Hybrid showed how electrification could make practical family transportation even more appealing. Its plug-in hybrid powertrain offered the ability to handle shorter trips on electric power while retaining the flexibility of a gasoline engine for longer journeys.
Audi E-Tron

The Audi E-Tron was an important step into the electric-SUV market. Rather than feeling experimental, it delivered the quietness and instant response of electric power alongside the luxury, comfort, and technology buyers expected from Audi.
Jaguar I-Pace

The I-Pace was one of the most interesting electric vehicles of the year. Its sleek design, dual-motor all-wheel-drive system, quick acceleration, and surprisingly engaging handling gave electric mobility a distinctly sporting personality.
2019 Audi A6

The redesigned 2019 Audi A6 brought a fresh take on the midsize luxury sedan, pairing understated styling with a high-tech cabin and impressive performance. Its turbocharged 3.0-liter V6 produced 335 horsepower and 369 pound-feet of torque, with Quattro all-wheel drive sending power to the road through a seven-speed dual-clutch transmission. It delivered a refined driving experience without sacrificing performance, making the A6 a memorable addition to our 2019 test-drive roster.