Automotive Tips

Automotivetip logo

2022 Volkswagen Golf GTI Takes Home Motor1 Star Award for Best Performance Vehicle

A perfect blend of everyday practicality and genuinely engaging performance.

Performance cars embody the passion that drives the automotive industry. For more than a century, automakers have pushed the limits of speed, handling, and driving excitement. That pursuit has produced an incredible range of vehicles, including three-row luxury SUVs capable of matching the acceleration of a Ferrari from two decades ago.

By 2021, performance was reaching new heights, with electric vehicles raising the bar for acceleration. Still, our contenders for Best Performance Vehicle aren’t newcomers. The 2022 Volkswagen Golf GTI and 2021 BMW M3 are the latest iterations of two iconic nameplates that have been thrilling drivers and earning critical acclaim for nearly four decades. Both continue that tradition, but while the M3 sits near the top of the four-door performance-car segment, we chose the GTI as our winner. Here’s why.

The Rivals

The Golf GTI is the benchmark for hot hatchbacks, and we’re not about to argue otherwise. It delivers an engaging driving experience without being intimidating, while offering the practicality you’d expect from a much less sporty car. We were impressed enough with the latest model to award it an 8.8-star rating during our first drive.

The eighth-generation GTI arrived for 2021 with a familiar turbocharged 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine and a choice of a seven-speed dual-clutch automatic or six-speed manual transmission. We’d choose the manual without a second thought, but our European-market test car came equipped with the dual-clutch gearbox. The US-spec version wasn’t available yet, though the mechanical differences between the two were relatively minor, and we’d already tested and rated the European GTI earlier that year.

The combination of turbocharged power and quick shifts makes for an entertaining drive. Volkswagen claims a 0–60 mph time of 6.3 seconds, but the GTI feels considerably quicker from behind the wheel. Its strong midrange punch and seemingly endless supply of torque make passing effortless, while the engine delivers plenty of response off the line. Despite sending power to the front wheels, the GTI also does a surprisingly good job of putting that power down without excessive wheelspin.

Our test car wears a considerably more aggressive set of tires than a standard GTI. The Bridgestone RE071R tires fitted to our tester aren’t available from the factory, but Volkswagen is offering a max-performance summer tire package for the first time. Select US-market GTIs will get Michelin Pilot Sport Cup 2 tires, and if they deliver even half the grip of these Bridgestones, they’ll be worth the upgrade.

The extra traction is complemented by a revised chassis. The headline change is a new aluminum subframe that’s both lighter and stiffer, but Volkswagen has also made several smaller adjustments to sharpen handling, including fitting stiffer springs. A new Vehicle Dynamics Manager replaces the previous drive-mode system, bringing significantly greater control over the adaptive dampers, XDS limited-slip differential, and stability control.

Inside, the GTI retains its familiar tartan upholstery, paired with redesigned two-piece sport seats. They provide plenty of support while featuring softer bolsters than the previous model, which should make longer drives more comfortable. The new three-spoke steering wheel is another welcome addition, though its touch-sensitive buttons are a frustrating misstep. Watch the video to see why.

Specification 2022 Volkswagen Golf GTI SE 2021 BMW M3 Competition
Engine Turbocharged 2.0-liter inline-four Twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six
Output 241 hp / 273 lb-ft 503 hp / 479 lb-ft
Transmission Seven-speed dual-clutch Eight-speed automatic
Drivetrain Front-wheel drive Rear-wheel drive
0–60 mph 6.3 seconds 3.5 seconds
Top Speed 155 mph (electronically limited) 180 mph
Fuel Economy 25 city / 34 highway / 28 combined mpg 16 city / 23 highway / 19 combined mpg
Curb Weight 3,046 pounds 3,890 pounds
Seating Capacity 5 5
Cargo Capacity 19.9 / 34.5 cubic feet 13.0 cubic feet
Base Price $29,545 + $995 destination $69,900 + $995 destination
Trim Base Price $35,290 $73,795
As-Tested Price $36,090 $92,095

The 2021 BMW M3’s bold new grille dominated conversations when the car debuted, often overshadowing the significant mechanical and driving improvements BMW brought to its latest sport sedan. The BMW M division had endured some challenging years, most notably with the previous-generation M3 and the fifth-generation M5, neither of which won universal acclaim. The latest M3, especially in Competition trim, makes a stronger case for itself with sharper handling, a more assertive character, and greater driving excitement. We awarded it 8.3 out of 10 when we tested it for the first time earlier that year.

Much of that appeal comes from under the hood. The revised twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six produces 503 horsepower and 479 pound-feet of torque, delivering the smooth, distinctive soundtrack enthusiasts expect from BMW. It strikes a pleasing balance between an engaging exhaust note and quiet, comfortable highway cruising without excessive droning.

Choosing the Competition model means accepting an eight-speed automatic transmission. The standard M3 is available with a six-speed manual, but that version gives up some horsepower and a substantial amount of torque. In Competition guise, the M3 rockets from 0 to 60 mph in just 3.5 seconds, making it a seriously quick sport sedan.

The M3’s powertrain is seriously impressive, even if the new automatic transmission doesn’t deliver the same aggressive jolt during full-throttle upshifts that BMW’s older dual-clutch gearboxes did. In exchange, the M3 is smoother and more refined during everyday commuting without sacrificing its track-ready character. The chunky paddle shifters are another highlight, offering a satisfying feel when changing gears.

The cabin’s standout feature, however, is the optional $3,800 sport seat package. Available with carbon-fiber backs and bold upholstery colors, including bright yellow and blue, these seats rank among the best factory performance seats available. They offer exceptional support, with firm bolsters keeping occupants securely in place through even the hardest corners.

And the M3 is more than capable of making the most of those seats. Its wider front track, standard Michelin Pilot Sport 4S tires, and revised suspension components deliver outstanding cornering ability. However, the car’s lightning-fast turn-in sparked debate among our editors. The steering responds almost instantly, sending the M3 toward its intended line with even the smallest input. That immediacy makes the car feel incredibly agile, but it also demands a smooth, deliberate approach from the driver.

Our Testing Process

We drove all our contenders on highways, country roads, and plenty of winding canyon routes, but our Best Performance Vehicle finalists received an extra round of testing. We rented Horse Thief Mile at Willow Springs International Raceway to push each car harder in a controlled track environment. There, we evaluated straight-line acceleration, agility, braking performance, and transmission behavior, comparing each contender with its rival and the wider market. Above all, though, we looked beyond the numbers and raw speed to determine what makes a performance car truly special.

A great performance car is about far more than its lap times or acceleration figures. The best machines connect drivers to the road and make an ordinary evening commute feel almost as thrilling as charging down Le Mans’ Mulsanne Straight. Since most drivers will never have the skills or opportunity to explore a modern performance car’s limits safely, these vehicles should make every journey feel special. They need to deliver accessible performance that inspires confidence, builds the driver’s abilities, and leaves room for mistakes without punishing them too harshly. Striking that balance is no easy feat, especially when passionate enthusiasts judge new models by something as specific as their Nürburgring lap times.

Why the Golf GTI Is Our Best Performance Vehicle of the Year

The GTI’s ability to help drivers improve while forgiving their mistakes is a major reason it takes the win. Newcomers will find plenty to love, from its punchy acceleration and reassuring steering feel to the freedom to fine-tune its various systems. More experienced drivers, meanwhile, will appreciate the precise adjustments they can make to the car’s behavior, both through its electronic settings and behind the wheel.

Best of all, the GTI is enjoyable in almost any situation. The M3, by comparison, feels most at home when driven hard, ideally at eight-tenths of its capabilities or beyond. Calling a car a tool may be a cliché, but BMW built the M3 with a specific purpose in mind, and it excels when used accordingly. The GTI is more versatile, delivering driving enjoyment whether you’re pushing it through corners or simply making your way through everyday traffic.

In the GTI, every corner feels like an opportunity for fun. The M3 can handle considerably more speed, but its hyperactive steering can become exhausting. The Volkswagen, by contrast, feels natural and inviting, offering reassuring stability during everyday driving and just the right combination of weight and responsiveness when the road gets twisty or the car hits the track.

We also can’t overlook the enormous price gap between these two cars, even if it wasn’t a deciding factor in our verdict. At $30,540, the GTI costs less than half as much as the $73,795 BMW M3 Competition. For drivers of any experience level, buying a GTI and investing the savings in advanced driving instruction makes more sense over the long term than splashing out on the faster, flashier BMW. Even without additional training, the GTI delivers an extraordinary amount of driving enjoyment for the money.

For all those reasons, and many more, the 2022 Volkswagen Golf GTI is our Best Performance Vehicle of 2021.

Other Winners

Scroll to Top